Salam and my utmost greetings to all.
For this task, the ESL website that I am going to evaluate is Randall's ESL Cyber Listening Lab. You can find the site by hitting the following address -
http://www.esl-lab.com/index.htm
Question 1
"What does the website attempt to "teach"? Are exercises included in the website? What are the types of exercises included? Are there immediate feedback? Are there different levels of difficulty for different proficiency levels?"
First of all, the website attempts to "teach" listening skills. There are thousands of audio clips provided by the site as part of the listening materials. The site provide a simple lesson plan; complete with the pre-listening, while listening, vocabulary as well as post-listening activities. There are, of course, exercises provided with each lesson. The exercises included multiple-choice and short-answer questions, mixed-up sentence,sentence and vocabulary question matching and also text completion quiz. The user can acquire their results straight away after they have completed the exercises and they can restart the quiz any time they want. The site has 6 different categories of lessons or quizzes in general. The categories are the General Listening Quizzes, Basic Listening Quizzes, Listening Quizzes for Academic Purposes, 20-Minute ESL Vocabulary Lessons, Language Learning and Life Tips, and last but not least, Long Conversations with Real Video. For each category, the lessons are divided into three levels of difficulties at most to cater to the different proficiency levels of the learners. Some of the quizzes have the Easy, Medium and Difficult level of difficulties while some have the Easy and Medium level only. The 20-Minute ESL Vocabulary Lessons and Language Learning and Life Tips section only have the Medium difficulty level. Meanwhile, the Listening Quizzes for Academic Purposes section has the Medium, Difficult and Very Difficult level of difficulty
Question 2
"What are the learners/visitors required to do with regards to learning the content of the website?"
The site is quite simple to use. It is free and no registration is needed to view the content, so it saves the visitors from the tedious process of accessing a protected site. There are only 3 small steps needed before we can start the listening lesson.
First - Choose a category. There are 6 categories of quizzes altogether, pick any one that suits your learning objectives and also looks appealing to you.
Second - Choose the level of difficulty. You can start of with Easy for some warm up lesson or you can just straight away jump to the Medium or Difficult level to suit your level of proficiency. The decision is all yours.
Third - Choose a topic. Each category is divided into columns of level of difficulties. In each of the column, there is a list of topics for the listening lesson. Choose topics that you find interesting to be challenged.
After you have chosen a topic, you will be directed to the lesson page. There, you can gain access to the full listening lessons; starting with the pre-listening activity and exercises, the audio clip followed by multiple-choice questions for the while-listening activity, vocabulary as well as post-listening activities. The visitors can choose to do all the suggested activities or just complete the exercises provided. One thing for sure, you have to listen to the audio clip first before you can try any of the exercises. That is the main lesson of the site; to get you to improve your listening skills. If you are visiting the site as part of your self-study, you can listen to the audio as many times as you want. This site is very beneficial for English teachers who are struggling to find fresh ideas and materials for a listening class because it covers all the three stages of listening task.
Question 3
"While you are going through the website, does it remind you of anything you do in a classroom, or with a teacher, or with a fellow classmate, or in self-study?"
I do remember the listening class I conducted with my students during practicum. The site has provided teachers with all the information required to conduct the lesson. The things left are the adaptation and execution. I realized that if I were to use the audio clips and adapt the activities suggested by the website to be conducted in my class, I need to ensure that I have full preparation in terms of the procedure of the lesson and also equipped with fully functioning devices. I remember one of the listening classes did not go well because the audio quality was so poor, using speakers (a mini speaker) to the max did not have any effect at all. At that time, I was trying to let the students listen to one of the audio clips found in the Ministry's CD-ROM that comes with the text book. The audio track might have worked well with a better and bigger-sized speaker. One thing that I noticed is that the exercises provided by the website were quite similar to the ones I used in the classroom even though I rediscovered this site a bit later after the lesson. For listening class, one of the most familiar exercises is the Text Completion Quiz where the students have to listen to the clips in order to fill in the blanks in the transcription of the audio. Other than that, matching questions are also suitable as a while-listening exercises. I'm also reminded of the days when I was studying Korean as a third language where I learned new vocabulary via podcast. I find that learning a new language through a variety of sources is very beneficial. There are a lot of things that I have learnt from the podcast that was unable to be covered due to time restrain in the class. In other words, learning through podcast enhances my understanding on the language. It also enables me to be more prepared in class as I have done my homework beforehand. I personally think that learning through podcast that can be accessed from sites similar to esl-lab helps a learner to understand the lesson better.
Question 4
"Does the website present learners with something that cannot be done in a textbook/workbook? If yes, how so?"
Esl-lab definitely presents learners with something that cannot be done in a textbook/workbook because the main teaching aid used is the audio clip. The textbook cannot possibly play an audio track. This is the trump card of the website - multimedia elements. Other than that, learners can straight away check their performance with only a simple click. Though learners can also check their works straight away after they have finished answering the exercises in the workbook, they still need to flip the pages for answers or ask the teachers to mark their score. Here, we can clearly see that technology has made life simpler and jobs easier.
Question 5
"Can you pinpoint some theories of language learning and/or teaching underlying the application?"
If we are talking about listening skills, we cannot ignore its relation with Gardner's Multiple Intelligence theory. According to the theory, an individual has at least 8 distinctive intelligence namely linguistic, logical-mathematical, spatial, musical,
bodily-kinesthetic, interpersonal, intrapersonal and naturalistic; all of which may vary in strengths and preferences(Gardner, 2006). Basing on the theory, language learning can be facilitated by addressing the different intelligence and then suit it with a broader scope of learners. Another theory in education that can be related to this site is the sensory-based learning style. There are 3 main methods of processing information which are through visual, auditory and tactile. Let us focus on the second modality; auditory. From the previous findings, Silverman (2006) derived three basic learning styles; of which one of it is the Auditory-sequential learning. Learners with this kind of learning style think in words and perceived information auditorily and basically learn in a sequential, step by step process (Cruse, no date).
Question 6
"An important criterion for evaluating a CALL program, task or activity is the potential for language learning. Does the website fulfill this criterion? If yes, how so?"
In terms of whether the website fulfill the criterion of having the potential for language learning, I would say yes. The site primary aim is to enhance learners' listening skill. As all four of main skills in language; reading, writing, listening and speaking; are interrelated to each other, improving listening skill would help the learners in other skills as well. For example, while they are listening carefully to the audio clip to fill in the gaps in the quiz script, they have to read the transcription one by one which encourages reading. Listening to correct pronunciation also helps improving their speaking skills. A bit trivia on this blog : the owner of the website state that the lessons and materials in this site are specifically designed for language learners. That is why I find that this site has a high language learning potential.Other than that, this site also acknowledges the importance of building learners' vocabulary. We can see that a vocabulary exercise is a must in each lesson. The website even included idioms that are related to the topic chosen on the left side of the page. There are links to Self-Study Guide and other ESL blogs for the users so that they can fully utilize the site. However, the site seems to be lacking something. The main page straight away shows the visitor the lists of topics for the listening lesson without introducing the page (what it is all about)and there is no instruction as to guide the users on what to do. Other than that, the site would be better if some notes on listening is included.
Question 7
"Would you like to use the application yourself in your future work?"
Yes? Give reasons :
No? Give reasons:
I would really love to use this website as part of my teaching resources in the future. One reason is that the site provided teacher-directed instruction which makes lesson planning an easier task. The listening quizzes are arranged according to the level as well as the topic, lexicon and syntax and also rate of speech. The additional pre-, while and post-listening activities provide support for the listening quizzes so that the lesson would be well-rounded. These facts would be a great help for teachers who are planning a lesson while trying to find materials that suits the students' proficiency levels. The use of audio clips would also makes learning an interesting experience. I also like the fact that the website focus solely on listening skills because it makes one know exactly what they are going to achieve by the end of each lesson while they gain other skills in incognito.